Jump to content
Search In
  • More options...
Find results that contain...
Find results in...

[Article] Are you a Manager or a Leader?


Jimi Wikman
 Share

Recommended Posts

  • Owner

It seems that the terms "leader" and "manager" are used a bit casually when you look at role descriptions and titles. The thing though is that they are not interchangeable, but actually have a very distinct definition in my opinion. Leaders lead and managers manage after all and those are two different skill sets.

Are you a project manager or project leader? That is a question almost no one ever ask, because in most people's mind they are the same. I would argue however that it is not because for me there is a very big difference between someone who lead and someone who manage.

 

A manager manage.

"Management (or managing) is the administration of an organization, whether it is a business, a not-for-profit organization, or government body. Management includes the activities of setting the strategy of an organization and coordinating the efforts of its employees (or of volunteers) to accomplish its objectives through the application of available resources, such as financial, natural, technological, and human resources. The term "management" may also refer to those people who manage an organization. "
- Wikipedia

Someone with the title manager is often someone who do not directly interact with the people they manage. They handle things like finances, stakeholder communication and reporting. In many ways managers work upwards to satisfy the need of those higher up in the hierarchy. People are often handled indirectly by managers and focus is on delivery and the promise given to those higher up in the organization.

Henri Fayol have a definition I think is quite accurate:  "to manage is to forecast and to plan, to organize, to command, to co-ordinate and to control."

Managers need strong skills in strategic planning and structured organization. As they often do not directly work with the people they manage they don't need strong charisma or empathic abilities. That is not to say that managers have these abilities, just that it is less required than for leaders.

Managers focus on the promise of delivery.

 

A leader lead.

"A leader is one who influences or leads others. 

Leadership is both a research area and a practical skill encompassing the ability of an individual or organization to "lead" or guide other individuals, teams, or entire organizations. Specialist literature debates various viewpoints, contrasting Eastern and Western approaches to leadership, and also (within the West) United States versus European approaches. U.S. academic environments define leadership as "a process of social influence in which a person can enlist the aid and support of others in the accomplishment of a common task"

Someone with the title leader is someone who directly interact with the people they lead. These are people who manage day to day activities within the team to ensure that the team are doing well. Leaders work downwards towards the team they lead and will shield them from the demands from those higher up in the organization.

Unlike management, leadership cannot be taught, although it may be learned and enhanced through coaching or mentoring. Erika Andersen, author of "Leading So People Will Follow," says, like most things – leadership capability falls along a bell curve. So the fact is that most folks who start out with a modicum of innate leadership capability can actually become very good, even great leaders.

We can define a leader and someone who possess a degree of leadership. Leadership can be defined as "The act of inspiring subordinants to perform and engage in achieving a goal."

In order to have others follow you, you need leadership skills and the respect of those that you lead. Empathy is a crucial skill as is charisma and compassion. As a leader you are also responsible for the promise of delivery and need organizational and strategic planning skills. It is just less required than for a manager.

Leaders focus on the promise to take care of the people.

 

Blurred lines between manager and leader.
It may seem that I make a hard distinction between managers and leaders. I know that the lines between the two are not as cut and dry as this article may suggest. Many managers are also great leaders and many leaders are great managers. The point I try to make is that the titles are not interchangeable, but they actually have a definition.

I think this is important because as long as we mix these roles when describing what role we actually are looking for, then we will continue to get the wrong skill set. This is even more confusing when adding a role definition based on an ability such as leadership.

Are you a sword or a shield?
This is a question I often ask when someone tell me they are a manager or a leader of some sort. Being a sword means that you will sacrifice the people to fulfill the promise of delivery. A shield on the other hand will protect the people even if it means sacrificing the promise of delivery.

Both of these types of managers are needed in an organization and you can often see the correlation when an organization are over representing one of the two. To many swords lead to a detached workforce and health issues among the teams. To many shields lead to difficulties to grow and economical issues.

In my perfect world we have a mix of both types throughout the organization. A higher focus on swords are at the top of the hierarchy and a higher focus on the shields are at the bottom. If we combine this with good communication and an organization model that focus work, then you have a perfect work environment.

So...are you a manager, or a leader?


View full blog article

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 0
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Similar Content

    • By Jimi Wikman
      In the past couple of weeks, I have had several interesting conversations about weird new roles and fields of work. Some are downright silly, like the UI Engineer, while others just seem unnecessary, like the field of Development Experience (DX). What is clear though is that people, especially from the USA it seems, have no idea what titles are in their field, so they make things up. This means that without definition work titles are pretty useless and this is where a proper database where we define roles will be important.
      While I find it interesting how young people, especially in the US, have an almost absurd desire to name themselves with titles of self-importance, it does cause a lot of confusion in the industry. Poor understanding of the work itself from the employers, and to some degree the people, is bad enough. It does not help that we add titles that make no sense or even add to the confusion.
      Hopefully we can create a database over these strange new things and evolve them together, since some new names is actually not that bad and others already exist and need to be adjusted. I already have the base, so it's just a matter of getting things put together and styling it. Unfortunately, I do not have an abundance of time right now, so it will be when time permits.
      Always moving forward though 🙂
    • By Jimi Wikman
      Mindful leadership is an approach in which you consciously cultivate your ability to be present, open-minded, and compassionate when interacting with team members – and you show the same consideration to yourself. Mindful leaders don’t need to motivate through fear or manipulation because their people are self-motivated.  By cultivating self mastery, mindful leaders are able to navigate stressful situations with calm and clarity.
    • By Jimi Wikman
      Leadership styles, just like everything else, evolve over time. 

      So what’s your personal style? Do one of the “classic” leadership approaches resonate with you? Or do you find that a more modern leadership theory is a better fit?

      Take our quiz to find out which of the traditional leadership styles you naturally gravitate toward. Then, refine your approach to leadership by stealing a few techniques from both the old-school and new-school leadership theories.
    • By Jimi Wikman
      According to a McKinsey survey, the pandemic accelerated the adoption of digital technologies globally by several years, pushing companies to migrate to the cloud, adopt distributed work models, and digitize their offerings. While ultimately positive, these changes were largely reactive. In order to shift their processes, many companies pressed pause on initiatives to drive innovation and instead focused solely on keeping the lights on in their businesses. For some, it was just the decision they needed to survive the economic squeeze of the pandemic. For others, it was the wrong choice – allowing competitors to gain critical headway.
      It’s never easy to choose between managing change or driving innovation within your organization. But with more changes on the horizon and rising competition promising stormy weather ahead, companies will increasingly have to make that same difficult choice. Here’s how you can plan your innovation journey – even when you can’t predict the weather.
    • By Jimi Wikman
      A database for roles related to the different areas of the development process listed on this site. Each role is defined with information such as responsibilities, mandate and so on. The idea is to provide a useful overview of each role that you can use as template for your organization, or as guide to how you can get to that position.

×
×
  • Create New...